THE BEST GLUTEN FREE PEANUT BUTTER OAT COOKIES

Over the Summer we visited Waco Texas home of Magnolia Market and Magnolia Silos bakery and the city that the fixer uppers: Joanna and Chip Gaines have taken to another level which was a total #bucketlist for me. I spent all last year in the Real Estate industry looking for my baking school and became obsessed with watching every fixer upper show on TV (and I rarely watch TV) so living the Waco life for a day was awesome! I highly recommend the visit!

The best part of Magnolia Silos Bakery were these peanut butter gluten free oat cookies which where by far better than any other pastry in the bakery (I tried many) and are even better than any “traditional” peanut butter cookie I have ever had. And I don’t say this lightly because if you know me you know that I go to a lot of bakeries!

So naturally I came back home and IMMEDIATELY wanted to recreate this cookie as soon as we drove back to Austin it was that life changing. So after making 4 really bad attempts and failing miserably at the texture and proportions I had to let it go (that seems to be my strategy for when things don’t go well: I surrender and let go: for a while..).

I then went to Mexico City to visit my Dad and teach 12 classes and workshops and since I had 7 awesome assistants and we had time and a lot of amazing ingredients we made the a killer recipe and I am thrilled to share it with you today. And I apologize in advance as my sharing of recipes is not that consistent as I want it to be but that is my creative process (plus I do a lot of other events, classes, collaborations that take time). So enjoy! This recipe is worth gold. And it’s not that “healthy” but a delicious alternative indulgence for those who can’t or don’t want to eat gluten. Just don’t say anything just make them and share!

 

THE BEST PEANUT BUTTER OAT COOKIES
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
A chewy peanut butter oat cookie that will change your life regardless if it's gluten free! My personal favorite!
Author:
Cuisine: Desserts
Serves: 14 medium
Ingredients
  • INGREDIENTS:
  • 120 grams European butter, unsalted at room temperature but still cold
  • 170 grams brown sugar (use only the very soft kind, I like the less dark one)
  • 4 grams fine sea salt
  • 60 grams eggs (mix and scale)
  • 8 ml vanilla extract
  • 15 grams almond milk
  • 180 grams my gluten free flour * (it is amazing!)
  • 6 grams gluten free and aluminum free baking powder (at high altitude use half)
  • 3 grams baking soda (at high altitude use half)
  • 150 grams gluten free oats such as Bobs Red Mill
  • 50 grams peanuts chopped
  • 100 grams peanut butter (I love Trader Joes Valencia peanut butter most of all).
  • @jacobsensaltco to sprinkle on top
Method
  1. Preheat convection oven to 350°F. Line a baking tray with a Silpat. Sift flour, baking powder and salt.
  2. In the mixer with a paddle, mix butter and sugar just until combined. Add egg, vanilla and mix well. Add oats and milk and mix well, add peanut butter and mix until combined.
  3. Add the sifted flour and combine just until incorporating—add the peanuts—mix well.
  4. Use a #24 Scoop and place the cookies onto the prepared cookie + flatten lightly onto the tray leaving enough room between them. Sprinkle with salt. Bake aprox 12 mins. Time depends on your oven.
  5. Cookies should be golden and crisp on the edges and ​tender​ inside. Don't over bake! Remember cookies will continue to bake when you remove them from the oven as they sit on the hot tray. Let cool for about 10 -12 minutes, remove and let cool on a cookie rack or place on a perforated tray.
Notes
Gluten Free flour blend: mix then measure what the recipe requires
INGREDIENTS: MAKES: 1,176 grams (you can make ½ recipe)
672 grams oat flour (must be #glutenfree) such as Bobs Red Mill
210 grams brown rice flour such as Bobs Red Mill
196 grams potato or arrowroot starch (any works)
84 grams tapioca starch
21 grams powdered coconut milk (as an emulsifier)
METHOD:
Mix all of the ingredients in a bowl. Measure the appropriate quantity called for in the recipe.

HEALTHY OATMEAL COOKIES OF MY DREAMS

Oatmeal cookies have always been my favorite travel cookies since I started doing recipe development for Starbucks Mexico in 2001.

We made multiple recipes for that project and they were delicious but so sugar loaded that it was unreal. I have since tweaked and adapted countless recipes and now that I am 95% gluten free (except for specific recipe testing) I wanted a killer oatmeal cookie recipe that was balanced, chewy, not too sweet, not oily, not sugar coated and not dry or cardboard tasting. My goal is to give you Master Recipes that will be your go to recipes you can build upon and do your own variation. If I had a bakery this would be my cookie of choice. I have not made this cookie vegan or dairy free yet: so before you guys ask me that question: please try my vegan oatmeal cookies (those are not gluten free) or try swapping the butter for vegan butter and egg for a flax egg. The Date Lady gave me the most amazing dates that taste like caramel and this inspired me to create a turtle version using her dates, pecans, chocolate and Maldon Salt. 

4.5 from 6 reviews
Oatmeal cookies of my dreams
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
GLUTEN FREE LOW SUGAR OATMEAL COOKIES Author: Vanessa Musi Serves: 16 cookies (made with a medium scoop size #24)
Author:
Serves: 16 medium
Ingredients
  • ½ teaspoon (2 gr) fine sea salt
  • 1 teaspoon Ceylon cinnamon (4 gr) (optional)
  • ⅛ teaspoon nutmeg or tonka bean (0.5 gr) (optional)
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda (at high altitude use ½ teaspoon)
  • 1 cup butter, unsalted (225 gr) (I love grass fed butter) at room temperature
  • 1 ¼ cups coconut sugar
  • 1 egg
  • 1 teaspoon (5 gr) vanilla
  • 3 cups gluten free oats
  • 1 cup gluten free flour such as Bobs Red Mill GF All Purpose Flour (blue label only)
  • ½ cup The Date Lady chopped dates
  • ½ cup 70 % chocolate chopped
  • ⅓ cup chopped pecans
  • Maldon salt to sprinkle on top
  • Variations: substitute dried cherries, yellow raisins, dried apricots chopped for the dates
Method
  1. Pre heat oven to 340 F or 170 C. Line 2 baking trays with Silpats.
  2. In a medium bowl: sift flour + baking soda, salt and spices.
  3. In a mixer with a paddle attachment: beat butter + coconut sugar until combined well (the goal is just to blend: not aerate as the cookies will spread if you do so).
  4. Add vanilla and egg and mix well. Add oats and combine. Add sifted flour mix and stir well. Add dates, chocolate, pecans, or desired add ins and mix well. Shape cookies with a scoop (I use a size #24) and place onto prepared cookie sheets: I place 4 lengthwise X 3 crosswise and flatten them out lightly. Sprinkle with Maldon Salt. Bake until golden for about 8-10 mins. They should be soft and chewy in the middle. Note: as they cool on the tray they will continue to bake, so make sure you don’t over bake them!
  5. Variations: I made these cookies with: pecans, chocolate and dates from The Date Lady and loved this “turtle” combination. I also made these with dried mangos with chile from Mexico and they were awesome!
  6. I also made a mix of yellow raisins, dates, dried apricots and added “unpumpkin” pie spice from The Raw Spice Bar to the cookies and they were amazing. I added 1 teaspoon instead of the cinnamon and nutmeg.
  7. Enjoy!!
  8. Please share the love on your social media and rate the recipe when you make it.
Notes
Gluten Free flour blend: mix then measure what the recipe requires
¾ cup brown rice flour must be superfine (I use Bobs Red Mill)
¼ cup potato starch
⅛ cup white rice flour must be superfine (I use Bobs Red Mill)
⅛ cup tapioca starch